
Aug. 11, 2025, 9:03 PM EDT
By Nkozi Knight
The argument over Gaza too often collapses into labels and talking points. That framing lets us dodge the only question that matters. Are we willing to watch human beings be starved, shot at while seeking food, and buried under rubble, and do nothing?
As of August 2025, more than 61,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since October 2023, according to figures collated by the U.N. from Gaza’s Health Ministry. Over 60,199 of those deaths have been fully identified by name and demographic details. Children are roughly one third of the dead. These are conservative counts and do not capture those still under collapsed buildings or the deaths from disease and hunger.
The health system is hardly a system anymore. The World Health Organization reports that at least 94 percent of Gaza’s hospitals have been damaged or destroyed. Many operate only in fragments, without reliable power, oxygen, or surgical capacity.
Schools have been leveled on a historic scale. U.N. satellite assessments show about 95 percent of school buildings damaged, with hundreds directly hit. The educational future of an entire generation is in jeopardy.
Hunger is now policy by other means. The global famine monitor (IPC) warns that the food-consumption threshold for famine has already been passed in most areas of Gaza, with malnutrition and deaths rising. UNICEF has documented a sharp increase in children dying of starvation and related disease. The U.N. continues to report paltry aid flows compared with need.
It is not just the volume of aid. It is the violence around it. After Israel dismantled the U.N.-led distribution system and backed a new contractor model this spring, multiple investigations documented civilians being shot at or killed around food sites and convoys. Hundreds have died seeking flour or canned food. These incidents are contested by Israeli authorities, but the pattern is now documented by journalists, doctors, and rights groups.
Claims that “Hamas steals all the aid” are often made to justify these restrictions. Yet a recent U.S. government review found no evidence of massive theft of U.S.-funded aid by Hamas, even as diversion risks exist in any war. Meanwhile, Israeli far-right activists and settlers have repeatedly blocked, vandalized, or looted Gaza-bound convoys. Both truths can be held at once. Aid must be protected from diversion, and people must be allowed to eat.
Christians are part of this story too. A Greek Orthodox church sheltering families was struck in October 2023, killing civilians. In December 2023, two Christian women were shot and killed inside the Holy Family Catholic parish compound, according to the Latin Patriarchate and the Vatican. The small Christian community has continued to suffer deaths and deprivation through 2024 and 2025.
Here is the moral core you asked to preserve:
This is not about being anti-Semitic.
It is not about being pro-Hamas.
It is not even about taking a side on Israel’s right to be in the Middle East.
It is about being human.
It is about the countless lives lost.
The countless lives destroyed.
The generations of families wiped from the earth.
It is about the deliberate starvation of people who are already trapped in devastation.
International law is not silent about any of this. The Genocide Convention defines genocide as specific acts committed with intent to destroy a protected group. Those acts include killing, causing serious bodily or mental harm, and inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about a group’s physical destruction. You do not need to be a lawyer to understand what “conditions of life” means when aid is throttled and families are shot at while queueing for food.
Courts have acted, even if governments have not. In January and again in May 2024, the International Court of Justice ordered Israel to prevent genocidal acts and to ensure unimpeded humanitarian access, including ordering a halt to the offensive in Rafah. In November 2024, ICC judges issued arrest warrants for Israel’s prime minister and former defense minister on charges that include using starvation as a method of warfare. In July 2025, the ICC rejected Israel’s bid to withdraw those warrants.
What should follow is not more argument. It is practical action.
Open the crossings wide and keep them open under neutral monitoring. Protect aid corridors and reinstate U.N.-led distribution at scale. Stop firing near food lines. Restore funding to agencies that have the reach to keep children alive. Enforce the ICJ’s orders. Respect the ICC process. None of this precludes holding Hamas accountable for the atrocities of October 7 or for any diversion of aid. It simply refuses to make civilians pay the price for crimes they did not commit.
History records the numbers. Conscience remembers the names. Gaza is not a referendum on anyone’s identity. It is a of our own.




















